“Agent” is currently one of the most commonly used words in the AI industry—and one of the most vague. Sometimes it refers to a chatbot, sometimes to an automated sequence of fixed steps, and sometimes to a system that decides for itself how to solve a task. For insurers, the difference is not merely academic. Anyone selecting a solution should know what it actually does—and what it doesn’t.
A common definition comes from Anthropic’s engineering blog. According to this definition, agents are systems in which a language model dynamically controls its own workflow and the use of tools, while retaining control over how it completes the task. An agent starts with an assignment or a conversation with a person. Once the task is clear, it plans and continues working independently, returning to the person as needed if information or an assessment is missing. In everyday insurance work, “tools” might include, for example, accessing a document, querying the policy system, or performing a calculation.
Anthropic contrasts this with the “workflow,” a system in which language models and tools collaborate along predefined paths. Anthropic refers to both together as “agent-based systems.”
Chatbot, Automation, Agent: The Difference
|
|
Chatbot |
Rule-based automation |
AI agent |
|
What it does |
Answers questions in a dialogue |
Performs fixed steps in a predetermined order |
Plans steps within a given framework and uses tools |
|
Who controls the process |
The user’s question |
The rules that were established in advance |
The model, within roles, permissions, and rules |
|
If something is missing |
Responds or says they don’t know |
Stop or refer the matter elsewhere |
Ask for clarification or hand it off to another person |
|
Example |
Information about a contract |
Automatic acknowledgment of receipt |
Evaluate a damage report, identify missing information, suggest next steps |
Not every task requires an agent. Anthropic itself advises choosing the simplest solution and increasing complexity only when necessary. Gartner also noted in 2025 that many use cases marketed as “agent-based” do not actually require agent-based implementation. At the same time, the analyst warned against “agent washing”: the practice of rebranding AI assistants, RPA, and chatbots as agents.
AI has long been in use in the industry. In the 2023 EIOPA survey, published in April 2024, half of the non-life insurers surveyed reported using AI, frequently in customer service, fraud detection, and claims processing. Agents represent the next level. Examples of tasks they can assist with (illustrative):
In 2025, Allianz Australia launched a system called “Project Nemo” consisting of seven specialized agents to handle small claims for spoiled food resulting from severe weather (under 500 Australian dollars). Individual agents plan the process, verify insurance coverage, cross-check weather data, watch for signs of fraud, calculate the payout, and finally compile everything for review. The decision to pay is made by a human. Allianz reports an 80 percent reduction in processing and payout time. These are company figures, not an independent audit. The division of labor is noteworthy: AI speeds up routine steps, while responsibility for claims processing remains with human agents.
Market researchers are also tempering the euphoria. Gartner expects that by the end of 2027, more than 40 percent of agent-based AI projects will be discontinued due to rising costs, unclear benefits, or inadequate risk controls. From this, we can conclude that technology alone is not enough: the task, benefits, and controls must be clearly defined in advance.
In the insurance industry, there’s the added factor that decisions have consequences for people—for example, regarding coverage, a claim denial, or customers in difficult situations. Such decisions belong in human hands. Our guiding principle is therefore: AI prepares, analyzes, and suggests; humans decide.
Which tasks within your organization would you entrust to an agent first, and what should it under no circumstances be allowed to decide on its own? We look forward to hearing from you.
Talk to us: tech11.com/en/sales
This article provides general information and is not a substitute for legal advice.
Sources: Anthropic, “Building effective agents” (Engineering Blog); Gartner, press release “Gartner Predicts Over 40% of Agentic AI Projects Will Be Canceled by End of 2027” (June 25, 2025); EIOPA, Report on the Digitalization of the European Insurance Sector (April 2024); Allianz, “When the Storm Clears, So Should the Claim Queue” (Newsroom, November 2025).